Does the world have enough lithium to move to electric vehicles?
Does the world have enough lithium to move to electric vehicles?
The world has enough lithium, but we need to scale up production this decade.
People have often worried that the world would run out of fossil fuels [see Hubbert’s curve on ‘peak oil’]. This concern is shifting to the minerals we need to build low-carbon technologies.
“The world doesn’t have enough lithium” is a common pushback against a move to electric vehicles.
In this article, I look at whether this true.
There are two separate questions we need to answer.
Does the world have enough lithium, or will we eventually run out? To answer this we need to look at cumulative demand and supply.
Can we mine and produce it quickly enough? To answer this, we need to look at annual demand and supply.
If you want the TLDR [Too long, didn’t read] version:
Yes, the world has enough lithium for our electric vehicles, decades into the future.
The world is currently not producing enough of it to keep up with demand. This could be a major bottleneck this decade.
Where does lithium come from and why do we need it?
First, some quick context.
Lithium is a key component of electric vehicle (and other) batteries. You might have heard of ‘lithium-ion’ batteries. They are very energy-dense, and have achieved massive improvements in their performance. In a previous post I looked at the plunging cost of lithium batteries; they have fallen by more than 98% since the early 1990s.1
To move to electric transport, lithium is one of our best shots. That’s why it’s so important.
We can get lithium from two sources.
First, it can be extracted from hard rocks in the ground, just like we imagine in traditional mines.
Second, it can be extracted from brine – that is, water rich in lithium salt. To get this lithium, salty groundwater has to be pumped to the surface and left to sit in large ponds for months on the end. When most of the water is evaporated away, lithium can be extracted.
We keep discovering more lithium, and we get better at mining it
How much lithium does the world have? We don’t really know for sure.
What we can estimate are ‘resources’: a ‘best guess’ of deposits that we’ve discovered and studied, and some that we think are there but are undiscovered.
Not all of these deposits are feasible to extract with our current technologies, or they are too expensive. The amount of lithium that we know we can technologically and economically mine are called ‘reserves’.
In 2021, it’s estimated that the world had 88 million tonnes of lithium.2 These are ‘resources’. One-quarter of this – 22 million tonnes – was feasible to extract. These are ‘reserves’.
What’s important about these figures is that they change all the time: we’re always discovering new lithium, and as our technologies and market conditions improve, more of our resources become economical to extract.
You might imagine that a chart of known reserves or resources over time would go down. But it’s the opposite: I’ve charted them below, and you can see them going upward because we're discovering new despoits much faster than we're using them up.3
When we really want something, we get good at finding it.
The world has enough lithium for the electric vehicle transition
Is 22 million – or 88 million – tonnes of lithium enough? How much do we need to switch from fossil fuel to electric cars?
There is a wide range of estimates, which depend on several factors: how quick and widespread EV adoption will be; the size of batteries; and how much lithium we’ll need per battery.
Let’s compare a range of estimates of the cumulative amount of lithium we’ll need by 2050. These come from several sources: the IEA’s projections based on countries’ stated policies, and its sustainable development pathway which accelerates this transition; estimates from a Nature study by Xu et al. (2020); and a study by the World Bank.4
These are shown in the chart, alongside the world’s current reserves and resources.5
The difference between 6 million, 18 million, or 25 million tonnes seems really large. But I don’t think this wide range is that important. It’s easy to imagine that decades from now, the chemistry of batteries will have changed so much that they will use two, three, or four times less than today. I’m more interested in the overall magnitude of these estimates – that they’re ten to twenty million tonnes (ish)– than the precise figures.
How many electric vehicles are we assuming in these scenarios? We can do a quick sense-check. The average EV currently needs around 8 kilograms of lithium.6 With our current 22 million tonnes of reserves, we’d get 2.8 billion EVs. With our 88 million tonnes of resources, we’d get 11 billion EVs.
Some of the figures in the chart look tight, compared to our reserves. But I don’t think that this is cause for concern. Markets and innovation respond to changes in supply and demand. We will inevitably find more reserves and resources. And, the chemistry of our batteries will change so that we need less lithium per pack.
Can we recycle lithium-ion batteries?
All of our numbers so far assume that demand has to be met through new lithium.
What if we could recycle lithium from batteries at the end of their life? This would be the ideal scenario. If recycling rates were high enough, we could almost completely close the loop on producing new batteries, or at least reduce the need to dig more out of the ground.
One problem is that recycling lithium is more expensive than mining new stuff. It might not stay this way. This used to be the case with lead-acid batteries: they were rarely recycled but after these markets scaled, almost all of them are today.
A better option is to not only recycle batteries – by grinding them up and extracting the minerals – but by repurposing them at the end of their life. This could be less expensive, but we’ve still to see it working at a commercial scale.
Even if we were to quickly increase recycling or repurposing rates, the demand for new lithium might not change much. At least, not very soon. There just won’t be very much material to recycle. Most EVs are still going to be on their first life by 2040 or 2050. Only later, when many are preparing for their second or third round, that recycling could make a dent in global lithium demand.
We are struggling to produce enough lithium this decade. We urgently need more production capacity.
I’m not that concerned about long-term lithium supplies. But our capacity to produce lithium at the moment is tight, and it’s having an impact on EV prices and supply.
In a previous article, I showed that the price of lithium-ion batteries has fallen by more than 98% since the early 1990s. But, this cost stalled last year, partly due to a rise in lithium prices. Prices are higher because supplies are tight.
We currently produce around 100,000 tonnes each year. By 2030, the IEA projects that we’ll need 2.5 to 5 times as much: 240,000 to 450,000 tonnes.
If you want to do some quick maths on this, let’s assume an EV needs 8 kilograms of lithium: that tonnage would give us 30 to 60 million new EVs per year.
The world doesn’t currently have the production capacity in mining operations to scale to this level. And, the problem is that the minimum time to build lithium mines is four to five years. They can be even longer – especially the lithium extracted from brine because it takes a long time to pump the saltwater out, before waiting for it to evaporate.
Countries have already invested in some increases in capacity, but we will need much more if we’re to keep up with demand.
This is a short-term challenge, and one that is typical of a fast-moving market. We’re playing catch-up. But, it’s a problem that we can’t afford: it could slow the decline in battery prices, and limit the number of EVs that companies can produce.
If we want to move the EV transition forward, we need to mine more lithium. And we need to do it quickly.
Which countries have lithium?
Where is this lithium going to come from?
A few countries currently dominate global production. This is shown in the chart. Australia produces more than half of the world’s lithium, followed by Chile, China, Argentina, then a number of small producers.
If the world is going to produce more lithium in the next five years, it’s going to come from a small number of countries: Australia, Chile, China, and Argentina.
In the longer term, we should look at each country’s reserves and resources. Known resources are shown in the chart below. We see some of the main producers near the top of the list. But we also see several countries that do not produce any lithium. Bolivia has the largest resources.
Our ability to increase lithium production might be limited to a few countries with production capacity already at scale, but over longer timeframes, many more countries could enter the race.
Ziegler, M. S., & Trancik, J. E. (2021). Re-examining rates of lithium-ion battery technology improvement and cost decline. Energy & Environmental Science, 14(4), 1635-1651.
https://about.bnef.com/blog/lithium-ion-battery-pack-prices-rise-for-first-time-to-an-average-of-151-kwh
I've taken this data from the US Geological Survey's (USGS) Lithium commodity report: https://www.usgs.gov/centers/national-minerals-information-center/lithium-statistics-and-information
To produce these charts, I found reserve and resources estimates in every year, from 2007 onwards, from the US Geological Survey (USGS).
These are published annually as PDF reports, which made for a fun time trying to pull the data out.
https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/global-production-of-lithium-by-route-2019-and-2050
https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/total-lithium-demand-by-sector-and-scenario-2020-2040
Xu, C., Dai, Q., Gaines, L., Hu, M., Tukker, A., & Steubing, B. (2020). Future material demand for automotive lithium-based batteries. Communications Materials, 1(1), 1-10.
Hund et al. (2020). Minerals for Climate Action: The Mineral Intensity of the Clean Energy Transition. The World Bank.
The IEA do not give explicit cumulative lithium production figures in its latest report. Instead, it gives estimates of annual production in decadal intervals.
To get these figures, I have done some basic back-of-the-envelope calculations, assuming there is an approximately linear annual growth each decade, and extending annual projections out to 2050 based on the decadal differences between 2020, 2030, and 2040.
These are rough estimates, and should not be treated as definitive figures. But they are within a reasonable range of other high and low estimates.
Castelvecchi, D. (2021). Electric cars and batteries: how will the world produce enough? Nature, 596(7872), 336-339.
All this analysis is assuming we use all available lithium for EV automobiles and trucks. A typical EV car has about 1000 lbs of batteries. Trucks can be up to 3000 lbs of batteries. Whereas a typical e-bike battery weighs up to 20 lbs. One car ~= 50 e-bikes. One truck ~= 150 e-bikes. As we try to replace gas cars and trucks with some form of EV, we have a once in a forever opportunity to change our minds on how an average person should get around. Let's not waste it.
Children are being forced to work in the mines to obtain the materials necessary for these batteries. It also comes at great environmental cost. https://junkscience.com/2020/10/mean-and-unclean-electric-cars-powered-by-child-labor-in-africa/
And what type of energy is used in mining these materials? It certainly isn't electricity. Furthermore, our electric grid is woefully inadequate to charge all the EVs if a majority of Americans owned one. What happens to the batteries at the end of their lifespan? They are expensive to recycle, even if that were possible. They will end up in landfills along with the giant, broken-down wind turbine blades. The cost of building all the charging stations that would be necessary is prohibitive. That is another cost that will be forced on taxpayers.
There is also the issue of time. How much is your time worth while you are waiting for your turn at the charger or waiting for the amount of time it takes to charge your vehicle? And I would hate to see what happened in a natural disaster if everyone owned EVs. How are you going to evacuate millions of Floridians when there's a hurricane if the power is out or they have to wait hours to charge their EV?
The price of EVs are way beyond the reach of most Americans, and that is even with all the taxpayer subsidies. Yes, others are paying for your EV. The true cost of these vehicles is hidden by the subsidies and toll charges being used to promote EVs. Money is merely a measure of value, and when government puts its thumb on the scales, it distorts the true cost and real value of what is being produced.
There are still the problems with range, of issues when the weather is cold, and the occasional EV bursting into flames while being charged.
Finally, the idea of man-made climate change is a hoax. It is designed to deliver more power to the globalist elites who want more control over our lives. The same people who have been saying sea levels will rise and wipe out the coasts have been buying multi-million dollar mansions right on the beach, and for at least 20 years, they have been scaring people by saying the world would end in 10 years. What is the carbon footprint of their mansions, private jets, and yachts? We are being conned.