Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Martin Nolan's avatar

You made another mistake by drawing your energy box around the car, excluding the energy losses associated with producing the electricity in the first place. Power plant efficiency can be as low as 25% for peak power, then there are transmission line losses, the more distance, the higher the loss, and finally inverter losses between the battery and electric motor of about 10%. And then, of course, in cold weather battery output can drop as a much as a third, and there are losses in hot weather as well.

Expand full comment
Nate Hagens's avatar

hi Hannah - nice analysis.

A small error (w large implications)

"But this is not true. With a switch to electric vehicles, we get rid of most of the ‘wasted’ energy from oil. "

You should write 'gasoline' here not 'oil'. Around the same amount of oil would have to be extracted and turned into many other products irrespective of whether all our cars run on gasoline or electricity. (ie only 40% of a barrel of oil is gasoline and the other 60% IS used and in high demand including the plastics, tires, etc in EVs, the asphalt in roads, etc).

Other than the oil for lubricants in engine etc, the wasted energy is from gasoline, not oil.

Expand full comment
62 more comments...

No posts