Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Winfried Theis's avatar

Thank you very much, Hannah, for your fantastic work! I think you are doing a great service to the sustainability movement by making this change! So I am already looking forward to see a broader mix of topics and maybe get a different perspective on some other topic as I may not have thought about the impact of making a certain change on some group in society or another aspect of the problem.

Have a great time over the holidays, Hannah and followers of this substack!

Expand full comment
Thomas Salter's avatar

Great! I occasionally find myself in debates with ‘green scam’ types over whether the two main human forces of the past two thousand years, market forces and state forces, are natural forces. They are not even though both have profound consequences for nature. The climate change and lost bio diversity and the rolling loss of forests cut down for charcoal about which you have kept us informed so clearly. And the profound health consequences. More children’s lives lost due to charcoal fumes than any disease or malnutrition. As we know only too well, extracting and selling oil and gas remains highly profitable for BP and the big 4. Gazprom and Aramco continue to fund the Russian and Saudi Arabian states. The FDLR still produces charcoal in the forests of the Virunga park, and it’s still sold in the markets of Goma under the watchful eyes of their enemies the M23. Markets and states supply our demands. They are our two most powerful creations. They make use of but they are not driven fundamentally by another of our greatest creations - science. Our world in data. The great challenge we face is how to make markets and states responsive to the environmental imperatives observed data reveals when their main drivers are not. I feel your need to branch out. It is brilliant that battery and PV costs have crashed, that copper is plentiful enough to build grids and we have the tech for the energy, transport and farming transitions. But the profit that drives the extraction of minerals and the movement of people and stuff around the world and the power that comes from winning votes or controlling a security apparatus remain stubbornly detached from carbon concentrations in the atmosphere. Data does not move that dial. So I commend your decision.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?